You are 100% correct in my opinion.
In my short time here, I’ve made massive leaps in my personal confidence as it relates to others, unto where if I am uncertain but very interested, I would just send an OOC to them asking the right questions. Busy? NP. Not interested? NP. Incompatible? NP. It’s a net cast with great care, but I am a deep-end individual and for me making that leap was possible. Often it toes the line between one thing or another or RL, but if ready to go I would just ask. What I really want to see, most of the time, when I’m looking? A character sheet that says “I can write!”, along with compatible tags, though I will play with almost anyone.
Everyone I have met is so kind, so giving and caring and gentle. That is a thing I did not anticipate. I’m sure that isn’t true of literally everyone, but it has been true for me. I genuinely have such kind feelings for everyone I have met so far.
In my own wanderings, there aren’t enough bad people that taking the risks of putting oneself out there is anything like RL… and every single one of us knows what those first moments, or even all of them, are like… the anticipation, fear, and hope- to whatever degree is a PART of what the experience currently is, and analogous in an emotional way to reality. Again, any change like matchmaking would be a paradigm shift, and as mentioned it is a gate: and not to keep people out, but to protect those too timid.
I want to mention that the highly HIGHLY accessible nature of the game and community, there being no gate upon basic entry, was a key factor in my landing here and I’d have that no other way, taking the good with the bad- but that also means anyone jumping in head first could have a bad time. Filters, filters, evermore.
Once desperate, now in ever so slightly greater fortitude and wisdom, I reject the idea of matchmaking as the game currently exists. I know for a fact that I am a person who would handle any approach with kindness no matter how awkward or obtuse and I think most others are the same.
Maybe, just maybe, we could enhance the ‘looking at you’ indicator or make it more obvious: but that is another rabbit hole of similar depth.
I hope this can help anyone that got this far into wanting such a feature to understand and I am very open to further discussion.